ACHL 
| 2024-25 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Cordell James | Stoney Creek Tigers |
| Leading Scorer | Cordell James | Stoney Creek Tigers |
| Top Goaltender | Daniel Svedin | Stoney Creek Tigers |
| Coach of the Year | Mark Ziliotto | Wentworth Gryphins |
| Trainer of the Year | Stephanie King | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Regular Season Champions | Wentworth Gryphins | |
| Robertson Cup Champions | Wentworth Gryphins | |
| Allan Cup Challenge Champions | Wentworth Gryphins | |
| 2023-24 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Mackenzie Wood | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Leading Scorer | Mackenzie Wood | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Top Goaltender | Matt Camilleri | Wentworth Gryphins |
| Coach of the Year | Ron Bernacci | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Trainer of the Year | Duane Butler | Wentworth Gryphins |
| ACH Executive of the Year | Rod Millard | Wentworth Gryphins |
| Regular Season Champions | Wentworth Gryphins | |
| Robertson Cup – OHA Senior “AAA” Champions | Stoney Creek Tigers | |
| Allan Cup Challenge Champions | Dundas Real McCoys | |
| 2022-23 | ||
| Top Goaltender | Daniel Svedin | Hamilton Steelers |
| Robertson Cup – OHA Senior “AAA” Champions | Hamilton Steelers | |
| Allan Cup Challenge Champions | Dundas Real McCoys | |
| 2021-22 | ||
| Season not played – COVID-19 pandemic | ||
| 2020-21 | ||
| Season not played – COVID-19 pandemic | ||
| 2019-20 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Adam Munro | Hamilton Steelhawks |
| Leading Scorers | Brad Bonello | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Best Defenseman | Justin DaSilva | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Most Sportsmanlike | Deron Cousens | Brantford Blast |
| Top Goaltender | Adam Munro | Hamilton Steelhawks |
| Rookie of the Year | Mackenzie Wood | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Coach of the Year | Ron Bernacci | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Trainer of the Year | Dr. Nicholas Anthony | Whitby Dunlops |
| Regular Season Champions | Hamilton Steelhawks | |
| Robertson Cup – OHA Senior “AAA” Champions | Hamilton Steelhawks led the Brantford Blast 2 games to 0 when Covid shutdown the rest of the postseason. | |
| 2018-19 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Justin DiBenedetto | Hamilton Steelhawks |
| Leading Scorers | Joshua Soares | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Best Defenseman | Dan Sullivan | Hamilton Steelhawks |
| Most Sportsmanlike | Phil Brewer | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Top Goaltender | Ryan DeMelo | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Rookie of the Year | Brett Mackie Guy Polillo | Whitby Dunlops Dundas Real McCoys |
| Coach of the Year | Marlin Muylaert | Whitby Dunlops |
| Trainer of the Year | Jenn Grioux | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Regular Season Champions | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| Robertson Cup | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| 2017-18 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Mathieu Cadieux | Whitby Dunlops |
| Leading Scorers | Phil Brewer Cam Fergus | Dundas Real McCoys Stoney Creek Generals |
| Best Defenseman | Matt Baxter | Whitby Dunlops |
| Most Sportsmanlike | Cameron Sault | Brantford Blast |
| Top Goaltender | Mathieu Cadieux | Whitby Dunlops |
| Rookie of the Year | Tyler Hore | Hamilton Steelhawks |
| Coach of the Year | Bryan Hamm | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Trainer of the Year | Dr. Nicholas Anthony | Whitby Dunlops |
| Regular Season Champions | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| Robertson Cup | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| Allan Cup Champions | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| 2016-17 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Chris Risi | Thorold Athletics |
| Leading Scorer | Chris Risi | Thorold Athletics |
| Best Defenseman | Sean Blanchard | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Most Sportsmanlike | Chris Risi | Thorold Athletics |
| Best Individual Goaltender | Daniel Svedin | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Best Team Goaltending | David Brown Matt Sagrott Daniel Svedin | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Rookie of the Year | Ben Skinner | Dundas Real McCoys |
| Coach of the Year | Shane Bowler | Whitby Dunlops |
| Trainer of the Year | Danny Bushey | Hamilton Steelhawks |
| Regular Season Champions | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| Robertson Cup | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| 2015-16 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | JJ Martin | Thorold Athletics |
| Leading Scorer | Mike Ruberto | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Best Defenseman | Simon Mangos | Dundas McCoys |
| Most Sportsmanlike | Darren Doherty | Whitby Dunlops |
| Best Individual Goaltender | Brett Leggat | Brantford Blast |
| Best Team Goaltending | Anthony Kimlin Jason Guy | Whitby Dunlops |
| Rookie of the Year (tie) | Jacob Ledyard Steven Dol | Brantford Blast Thorold Athletics |
| Coach of the Year | Kevin Bolibruck | Thorold Athletics |
| Trainer of the Year | Danny Bushey | Hamilton Steelhawks |
| Regular Season Champions | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| Robertson Cup | Stoney Creek Generals | |
| 2014-15 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Darren Doherty | Norwood Vipers |
| Leading Scorer | Derek Medeiros | Brantford Blast |
| Best Individual Goaltender | Anthony Marshall Jason Guy | Brantford Blast Whitby Dunlops |
| Coach of the Year | Jeff McCormick | Brantford Blast |
| Trainer of the Year | Jennifer Giroux | Stoney Creek Generals |
| Regular Season Champions | Whitby Dunlops | |
| Robertson Cup | Dundas Real McCoys | |
| Allan Cup Champions | Dundas Real McCoys | |
| 2013-14 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Joel Prpic | Brantford Blast |
| Leading Scorer | John Scrymgeour | Whitby Dunlops |
| Best Individual Goaltender | Brett Leggat | Brantford Blast |
| Coach of the Year | Mike Posavad | Whitby Dunlops |
| Trainer of the Year | Ashley Stainton | Whitby Dunlops |
| Regular Season Champions | Dundas Real McCoys | |
| Robertson Cup | Brantford Blast | |
| Allan Cup Champions | Dundas Real McCoys | |
| 2012-13 | ||
| Most Valuable Player & OHA MVP | Travis Fuller | Orillia Tundras |
| Leading Scorer | Michael Ruberto | Brantford Blast |
| Best Individual Goaltender | Brett Leggat | Brantford Blast |
| Coach of the Year | Mike Burgoyne | Brantford Blast |
| Trainer of the Year | Ashley Stanton | Whitby Dunlops |
| Regular Season Champions | Brantford Blast | |
| Robertson Cup | Brantford Blast | |
| 2011-12 | ||
| Most Valuable Player | Cam Watson | Dundas McCoys |
| Leading Scorer | Cam Watson | Dundas McCoys |
| Best Defenseman | Mike Burgoyne | Brantford Blast |
| Most Sportsmanlike | Jason McAuley | Whitby Dunlops |
| Best Individual Goaltender | Joel Whitmarsh | Whitby Dunlops |
| Best Team Goaltending | Joel Whitmarsh Anthony Kimlin Wes Annis Matt Balsar | Whitby Dunlops |
| Rookie of the Year | Walter Easter | Brantford Blast |
| Coach of the Year | Tom Ruff | Orillia Tundras |
| Trainer of the Year | Jenn Sumerville | Dundas McCoys |
| Regular Season Champions | Whitby Dunlops | |
| Robertson Cup | Dundas Real McCoys | |
| 2010-11 | ||
| First Team All Stars | Ryan Ashaber – Goaltender Kyle Searle – Left Defense Jeremy Bloomfield – Right Defense Chad Spurr – Centre Jason McAuley – Left Wing Peter MacKellar – Right Wing Head Coach: Matt Armstrong Manager: Steve Cardwell Trainer: Amanda Bolen | Various Teams |
| Second Team All Stars | Joel Whitmarsh – Goaltender Matt Cardwell – Left Defense Tom Brown – Right Defense Adam Van Dam – Centre Leiland Gauley – Left Wing Dennis Dewar – Right Wing Head Coach: Tom Ruff Manager: Tom Ruff Trainer: Ray McColeman | Various Teams |
| 2009-10 | ||
| First Team All Stars | Brian Worosz – Goaltender Craig Woods – Left Defense Bob McQuat – Right Defense Nick Smith – Centre Ryan Christie – Left Wing Ryan Kuwabara – Right Wing Coach: Mike Posavad Manager: Don Roberston Trainer: Ray McColeman | Various Teams |
| Second Team All Stars | Ryan Ashaber – Goaltender Matt Cardwell – Left Defense Gerry Galway – Right Defense Shane Terry – Centre John Vecchiarelli – Left Wing Dennis Dewar – Right Wing Coach: Ken Mann Manager: Wayne Crawford Trainer: Joe Russelle | Various Teams |